| Player | Pos. | Ht. | Yr. | Recognition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elwood S. Romney | 1931 | Helms (1st), College Humor (3rd), Consensus | ||
| 1932 | Helms (1st) | |||
| Joe Nelson | F | 6-3 | 1948 | Helms (2nd), GlobeTrotters Tour |
| Mel Hutchins | C | 6-5 | 1951 | Helms (1st), Sporting News (1st), Converse Yearbook (1st), Look Magazine (1st), INS (1st), UPI (3rd), AP (3rd) |
| Roland Minson | F | 6-0 | 1951 | Converse Yearbook (4th) |
| Joe Richey | F | 6-1 | 1953 | Colliers (2nd), INS (2nd), Look Magazine (2nd), Helms(3rd) |
| Dean Larsen | F | 6-2 | 1954 | Helms (2nd) |
| Terry Tebbs | G | 5-9 | 1956 | UPI Little (1st) |
| Tom Steinke | G | 5-10 | 1957 | UPI Little (1st), Helms (2nd) |
| Gary Earnest | G | 6-0 | 1961 | UPI (HM) |
| John Fairchild | C | 6-8 | 1965 | Helms, NABC (3rd) |
| Dick Nemelka | G | 6-0 | 1966 | Helms, Converse Yearbook (1st), USBWA (1st), NABC (3rd) |
| Kresimir Cosic | C | 6-11 | 1972 | Helms, Converse Yearbook (2nd), UPI (3rd), NABC (4th) |
| 1973 | Helms, NABC (4th), Citizen Saving Athletes Foundation | |||
| Danny Ainge | G | 6-5 | 1979 | NABC (4th) |
| 1980 | Helms, NABC (3rd), Academic (1st) | |||
| 1981 | Consensus, Helms, AP (1st), NABC (1st), UPI (1st), Sporting News (1st), Converse Yearbook (1st), Basketball Times (1st), Wooden Award, Eastman Award, USBWA (2nd), Academic (1st) | |||
| Devin Durrant | F | 6-7 | 1983 | Academic (1st) |
| 1984 | Wooden (1st), AP (2nd), NABC (2nd), USBWA (2nd), Sporting News (2nd), Basketball Times (2nd), UPI (3rd) | |||
| Michael Smith | F | 6-10 | 1987 | Academic (1st) |
| 1988 | USBWA (2nd), UPI (2nd), Basketball Times (2nd), AP (3rd), Basketball Weekly (3rd), Sporting News (HM), Academic (1st) | |||
| 1989 | Academic (1st) | |||
| Jeff Chatman | F | 6-6 | 1988 | Sporting News (HM) |
| Andy Toolson | F | 6-6 | 1990 | Academic (1st) |
| Shawn Bradley | C | 7-6 | 1991 | Basketball Times Freshman (1st) |
| Nate Call | G | 6-0 | 1992 | AP (HM) |
| Gary Trost | C | 6-10 | 1993 | AP (HM) |
| Randy Reid | G | 6-2 | 1994 | Academic (3rd) |
| Russell Larson | F | 6-11 | 1995 | Academic (1st) |
| Mekeli Wesley | F | 6-9 | 2001 | AP (HM) |
| Rafael Araujo | C | 6-11 | 2004 | Basketball Times (2nd), AP (HM) |
| Trent Plaisted | F/C | 6-11 | 2006 | Scout.com Freshman (2nd) |
| Keena Young | F | 6-6 | 2007 | AP (HM) |
| Lee Cummard | G/F | 6-7 | 2008 | AP (HM) |
| 2009 | FoxSports.com (4th) | |||
| Jimmer Fredette | G | 6-2 | 2010 | AP (HM), Sporting News (3rd), NABC State Farm Coaches' (3rd), Basketball Times (2nd), Lute Olson |
| 2011 | AP (1st), John R. Wooden (1st), Sporting News (1st), NABC State Farm Coaches' (1st), USBWA (1st), CBSSports.com (1st), SI.com (1st), Yahoo! Sports (1st), FoxSports.com (1st), Lute Olson |