| Opponent | Record | Last Played | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| American University (Puerto Rico) | Overall: 1-0 Home: 1-0 | 1999 | BYU, 3-0 A |
| Ball State | Overall: 14-6 Home: 10-2 Away: 4-2 Neutral: 0-2 | 2023 | BSU, 3-1 A |
| Barton | Overall: 3-0 Home: 2-0 Neutral: 1-0 | 2018 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Cal Baptist | Overall: 22-3 Home: 18-2 Away: 4-1 | 2017 | BYU, 3-1 H |
| CSUN | Overall: 40-22 Home: 23-8 Away: 17-14 | 2017 | BYU, 3-1 A |
| Concordia Irvine* | Overall: 7-2 Neutral: 1-0 | 2023 | BYU, 3-1 N |
| Concordia, New York | Overall: 4-0 Home: 4-0 | 2003 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Eastern Montana (Montana State Billings) | Overall: 1-0 Home: 1-0 | 1991 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Fairleigh Dickinson | Overall: 2-0 Home: 2-0 | 2023 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| George Mason | Overall: 3-2 Home: 2-0 Road: 0-1 Neutral: 1-1 | 2016 | BYU, 3-1 H |
| Grand Canyon* | Overall: 3-5 Home: 2-2 Away: 1-3 | 2023 | GCU, 3-2 A |
| Hawai'i | Overall: 41-19 Home: 25-4 Away: 15-14 Neutral: 1-2 | 2019 | UH, 3-0 H |
| IPFW | Overall: 4-4 Home: 0-2 Road: 3-0 Neutral: 1-2 | 2009 | BYU, 3-0 N |
| La Verne | Overall: 2-0 | 2001 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Lewis | Overall: 16-3 | 2023 | BYU, 3-1, H |
| Long Beach State | Overall: 33-23 Home: 18-8 Away: 11-14 Neutral: 4-1 | 2017 | BYU, 3-0 N |
| Loyola-Chicago | Overall: 5-5 | 2018 | LUC, 3-2 H |
| Loyola Marymount | Overall: 18-2 Home: 10-1 Away: 8-1 | 2000 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| McKendree | Overall: 3-1 Home: 3-1 | 2023 | BYU, 3-0, H |
| Ohio State | Overall: 15-6 Home: 8-3 Away: 6-2 Neutral: 1-1 | 2023 | BYU, 3-2 H |
| NJIT | Overall: 1-0 Away: 1-0 | 2016 | BYU, 3-0 A |
| Pacific | Overall: 32-5 Home: 19-0 Away: 12-5 Neutral: 1-0 | 2014 | BYU, 3-1 A |
| Park College | Overall: 1-0 Home: 1-0 | 1998 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Penn State | Overall: 13-8 Home: 3-3 Away: 6-3 Neutral: 4-2 | 2022 | Penn, 3-0 A |
| Pepperdine* | Overall: 38-35 Home: 23-9 Away: 12-26 | 2023 | BYU, 3-2 H |
| Princeton | Overall: 3-0 Home: 2-0 Away: 1-0 | 2019 | BYU, 3-2 H |
| Quincy | Overall: 1-0 Home: 1-0 | 2001 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Rutgers | Overall: 5-2 Home: 3-0 Away: 1-1 Neutral: 1-1 | 2006 | BYU, 3-0 N |
| San Diego State | Overall: 9-2 Home: 6-0 Away: 3-2 | 2000 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| Stanford* | Overall: 40-25 Home: 21-7 Away: 18-15 Neutral: 1-3 | 2023 | STAN, 3-2 A |
| St. Francis (PA) | Overall: 2-0 Away: 2-0 | 2019 | BYU, 3-0 A |
| UC Irvine | Overall: 51-21 Home: 27-7 Away: 24-10 Neutral: 0-4 | 2023 | BYU, 3-2 A |
| UCLA* | Overall: 36-38 Home: 24-12 Away: 11-25 Neutral: 1-1 | 2023 | UCLA, 3-0 A |
| UC San Diego | Overall: 43-2 Home: 22-2 Away: 21-0 | 2022 | UCSD, 3-2 H |
| UC Santa Barbara | Overall: 44-26 Home: 27-9 Away: 17-17 | 2023 | BYU, 3-1 H |
| UC Santa Cruz | Overall: 3-0 Home: 3-0 | 1999 | BYU, 3-0 H |
| USC* | Overall: 43-16 Home: 27-4 Away: 15-12 Neutral: 1-0 | 2023 | BYU, 3-1 H |
| Winnipeg | Overall: 2-0 Home: 2-0 | 1999 | BYU, 3-0 H |
*MPSF opponent