Seven BYU women's volleyball student-athletes have earned a total of 11 CoSIDA Academic All-American citations. In addition, Dylann Duncan Ceriani was inducted into the CoSIDA Academic All-America Hall of Fame in 2004.

Year Team Name Position
2018 3rd Roni Jones-Perry Outside hitter
2016 1st Amy Boswell Middle blocker
2015 1st Amy Boswell Middle blocker
2006 3rd Lindsy Hartsock Middle blocker
1997 1st Amy Steele Gant Middle blocker
1996 3rd Amy Steele Gant Middle blocker
1992 1st Shannon Egbert Skidmore Outside hitter
1988 2nd Dylann Duncan Ceriani Middle blocker
1987 1st Dylann Duncan Ceriani Middle blocker
1986 3rd Dylann Duncan Ceriani Middle blocker
1982 1st Valerie de Pourtales Setter