BYU has had 38 athletes earn 110 All-America citations in its history, including 40 named first-, second-, or third-team AVCA All-America. The 40 All-Americans is good for 10th all-time among Division I programs. 

In 2018, six Cougars earned an All-America citation, the most in a single season in program history.

All-Americans
YearPlayerOutletTeam
2022Heather GneitingAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
 Erin LivingstonAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
2021Kenzie KoerberAVCA3rd
  VolleyballMag.com3rd
 Whitney BowerAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.com3rd
 Kennedy EschenbergAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
 Heather GneitingVolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
2020-21Kennedy EschenbergAVCA3rd
  VolleyballMag.com4th
 Taylen Ballard-NixonAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
 Whitney BowerAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.com3rd
2019Mary LakeAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.com3rd
 McKenna MillerAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.com3rd
 Whitney BowerVolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
2018Roni Jones-PerryAVCA1st
  VolleyballMag.com1st
 Lyndie Haddock EppichAVCA1st
  VolleyballMag.com1st
 Mary LakeAVCA2nd
  VolleyballMag.com1st
 Heather GneitingAVCA3rd
  VolleyballMag.com4th
 Kennedy EschenbergAVCAHonorable Mention
 McKenna MillerAVCAHonorable Mention
  VolleyballMag.comHonorable Mention
2017Roni Jones-PerryAVCA3rd
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 Cosy BurnettAVCAHonorable Mention
 Mary LakeAVCAHonorable Mention
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 McKenna MillerAVCAHonorable Mention
  Volleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
2016Amy BoswellAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 McKenna MillerAVCA3rd
  Volleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
2015Alexa GrayAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 Amy BoswellAVCA3rd
2014Jennifer HamsonAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 Alexa GrayAVCA2nd
 Amy BoswellAVCAHonorable Mention
 Whitney Young HowardVolleyball Magazine2nd
2013Alexa GrayAVCA3rd
2012Jennifer HamsonAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 Alexa GrayAVCAHonorable Mention
 Heather HannemannAVCAHonorable Mention
 Nicole WarnerAVCAHonorable Mention
  Volleyball Magazine3rd
2011Jennifer HamsonAVCAHonorable Mention
2007Chelsea GoodmanAVCA3rd
  Volleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
 Rachel DyerAVCAHonorable Mention
2006Chelsea GoodmanAVCAHonorable Mention
  Volleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
2005Lindsy HartsockAVCAHonorable Mention
 Lauren Richards EvansAVCAHonorable Mention
2000Nina PuikkonenAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine1st
1999Nina PuikkonenAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
 Anna-Lena SmithAVCA2nd
1998Korie RogersAVCA2nd
 Anna-Lena SmithAVCA2nd
1997Amy Steele GantAVCA1st
  Volleyball Magazine1st
 Korie RogersAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Magazine2nd
1996Gale JohnsonAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Magazine3rd
 Amy Steele GantVolleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
1995Amy Steele GantAVCA2nd
  Volleyball MagazineHonorable Mention
1994Charlene JohnsonAVCA2nd
1993Charlene JohnsonAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly3rd
 Michele FellowsAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly1st
1992Michele FellowsAVCA2nd
  Volleyball MonthlyHonorable Mention
 Tea NieminenAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Monthly3rd
1990Tea NieminenAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Monthly Honorable Mention
1988Dylann Duncan CerianiAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly2nd
1987Mariliisa SalmiAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly1st
 Jill Sanders PlumbAVCA1st
  Volleyball MonthlyHonorable Mention
 Dylann Duncan CerianiAVCA2nd
1986Mariliisa SalmiAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly1st
 Sari VirtanenAVCA1st
  Volleyball Monthly1st
1985Sari VirtanenAVCA2nd
  Volleyball Monthly3rd
1984Karen DoaneAVCA2nd
  Volleyball MonthlyHonorable Mention
1983Madge FerreiraVolleyball MonthlyHonorable Mention
1981Lisa Motes ConnollyAVCA1st
1979Lisa Motes ConnollyVolleyball MonthlyHonorable Mention
1977Annette CottleVolleyball Monthly2nd
 Karen Curtis LambVolleyball Monthly2nd
All-Freshman Team
YearPlayerOutlet
2019Whitney BowerVolleyballMag.com (Honorable Mention)
2018Heather GneitingVolleyballMag.com
1999Sunny Tonga MaheVolleyball Magazine
1998Nina PuikkonenVolleyball Magazine
1991Charlene JohnsonVolleyball Magazine