2021 | NCAA Regional (Tempe, Ariz.) |
| Virginia Tech 5, BYU 3 |
| BYU 7, Southern Illinois 2 |
| BYU 9, Arizona State 8 |
| Virginia Tech 11, BYU 3 (5) |
| |
2019 | NCAA Regional (Stillwater, Okla.) |
| Oklahoma State 3, BYU 1 |
| BYU 6, Arkansas 3 |
| Tulsa 6, BYU 4 |
| |
2018 | NCAA Regional (Eugene, Ore.) |
| Drake 3, BYU 2 |
| BYU 16, UAlbany 0 (5) |
| Drake 3, BYU 0 |
| |
2017 | NCAA Regional (Salt Lake City, Utah) |
| BYU 8, Mississippi State 0 (5) |
| Utah 3, BYU 2 |
| BYU 12, Fordham 1 (5) |
| Utah 14, BYU 0 (6) |
| |
2016 | NCAA Regional (Columbia, Mo.) |
| Missouri 9, BYU 0 (5) |
| BYU 6, Louisville 4 |
| Nebraska 2, BYU 0 |
| |
2015 | NCAA Regional (Eugene, Ore.) |
| Oregon 8, BYU 0 |
| BYU 8, Fresno State 7 |
| North Dakota State 7, BYU 0 |
| |
2014 | NCAA Regional (Seattle, Wash.) |
| BYU 7, Northwestern 2 |
| Washington 9, BYU 0 |
| Northwestern 8, BYU 3 |
| |
2013 | NCAA Regional (Eugene, Ore.) |
| Oregon 5, BYU 2 |
| Wisconsin 6, BYU 0 |
| |
2012 | NCAA Regional (Eugene, Ore.) |
| BYU 4, Mississippi State 3 |
| Oregon 6, BYU 4 |
| BYU 2, Portland State 0 |
| Oregon 4, BYU 1 |
| |
2011 | NCAA Regional (Seattle, Wash.) |
| BYU 2, Auburn 1 |
| Washington 4, BYU 1 |
| BYU 4, Auburn 3 |
| Washington 7, BYU 5 |
| |
2010 | NCAA Regional (Austin, Texas) |
| BYU 1, East Carolina 0 |
| BYU 9, Texas 8 |
| BYU 8, East Carolina 3 |
| |
| NCAA Super Regional (Tuscon, Ariz.) |
| Arizona 2, BYU 1 |
| Arizona 10, BYU 2 |
| |
2009 | NCAA Regional (Columbus, Ohio) |
| BYU 6, Kentucky 2 |
| Ohio State 5, BYU 4 |
| Kentucky 4, BYU 2 |
| |
2008 | NCAA Regional (Chapel Hill, N.C.) |
| BYU 3, North Carolina 0 |
| Georgia 9, BYU 3 |
| BYU 1, Campbell 0 |
| Georgia 4, BYU 0 |
| |
2007 | NCAA Regional (Provo, Utah) |
| BYU 9, Cal Poly 0 |
| Arizona State 7, BYU 1 |
| BYU 10, Southern Utah 5 |
| Arizona State 6, BYU 3 |
| |
2006 | NCAA Regional (Provo, Utah) |
| Kansas 3, BYU 0 |
| BYU 5, Southern Utah 4 |
| Kansas 2, BYU 1 |
| |
2005 | NCAA Regional (Fresno, Calif.) |
| BYU 3, California 1 |
| Fresno State 3, BYU 0 |
| California 9, BYU 0 |
| |
2001 | NCAA Regional (Palo Alto, Calif.) |
| Nebraska 2, BYU 0 |
| Hofstra 4, BYU 2 |