2024
- Team: 1st Round: BYU vs. Auburn
2007
- Team: 1st Round: BYU def. Oregon, 4-0
- Team: 2nd Round: Stanford def. BYU, 4-0
2006
- Team: 1st Round: Arizona def. BYU, 4-1
2005
- Team: BYU def. Sacramento State, 4-1
- Team: Baylor def. BYU, 4-1
2004
- Team: 1st Round: Pepperdine def. BYU, 4-2
2002
- Team: 1st Round: California def. BYU, 4-0
2001
- Team: 1st Round: Alabama def. BYU, 4-3
- Singles: 1st Round: Adria Engel (Arizona State) def. Jodi Richardson, 4-6, 6-2, 6-3
- Doubles: 1st Round: Katja Kovac/Jahnavi Parakh (Baylor) def. Brooke Ferney/Jodi Richardson, 6-3, 7-6
1998
- Team: 1st Round: Wake Forest def. BYU, 5-4
1997
- Team: 1st Round: BYU def. New Mexico, 5-3
- Team: 2nd Round: Mississippi def. BYU, 0-5
- Singles: Eline Chiew
1996
- Team: 1st Round: Notre Dame def. BYU, 5-0
- Singles: 1st Round: Eline Chiew def. Marikia Andrade (Mississippi State) 4-6, 6-2, 6-3
- Singles: 2nd Round: Keri Phebus (UCLA) def. Eline Chiew, 6-3, 6-1
1995
- Team: 1st Round: South Carolina def. BYU, 5-3
- Singles: 1st Round: Joelle Schad (Arizona State) def. Jennifer Saret, 6-1, 6-3
1993
- Team: 1st Round: BYU def. Virginia, 5-2
- Team: 2nd Round: Florida def. BYU, 5-0
1991
- Team: 2nd Round: Arizona def. BYU, 7-2
1990
- Team: 1st Round: Arizona def. BYU, 6-0
1989
- Team: 2nd Round: Oklahoma State def. BYU, 7-2
1988
- Team: 1st Round: BYU def. South Carolina, 5-4
- Team: 2nd Round: USC def. BYU, 5-1
1987
- Team: 1st Round: SMU def. BYU, 6-3
1982
- Team: 1st Round: Rollins def. BYU, 5-4