BYU is home to 85 All-Americans with 14 multi-year honorees. Eldon Fortie began BYU’s long line of All-Americans in 1961 and Marc Wilson was BYU’s first consensus All-American in 1979. BYU boasts 14 consensus All-Americans as well as an additional 34 Academic All-Americans.
| PLAYER | YEARS |
|---|---|
| Eldon Fortie | 1961 |
| Jay Miller | 1973, 1974 |
| Wayne Baker | 1974 |
| Brad Oates | 1975 |
| Jeff Blanc | 1975 |
| Orrin Olsen | 1975 |
| Gifford Nielsen | 1976 |
| Marc Wilson | 1979 (c) |
| Clay Brown | 1980 |
| Nick Eyre | 1980 (c) |
| Jim McMahon | 1980, 1981 (c) |
| Bart Oates | 1982 |
| Gordon Hudson | 1982 (c), 1983 (c) |
| Steve Young | 1983 (c) |
| Robbie Bosco | 1984 |
| Kyle Morrell | 1984 |
| Leon White | 1984 |
| Marv Allen | 1984 |
| David Mills | 1984 |
| Mark Bellini | 1985 |
| Trevor Matich | 1985 |
| Trevor Molini | 1985 |
| Jason Buck | 1986 (c) |
| Pat Thompson | 1988 |
| Mo Elewonibi | 1989 (c) |
| Bob Davis | 1989 |
| Chris Smith | 1989, 1990 (c) |
| Ty Detmer | 1990 (c) 1991 (c) |
| PLAYER | YEARS |
|---|---|
| Byron Rex | 1992 |
| Alan Boardman | 1993 (f) |
| Evan Pilgrim | 1994 |
| Steve Sarkisian | 1996 |
| Itula Mili | 1996 |
| Rob Morris | 1999 |
| Luke Staley | 1999 (f), 2001 (c) |
| Matt Payne | 2002, 2004 |
| Daniel Coats | 2003 (f) |
| Austin Collie | 2004 (f), 2008 |
| Dallas Reynolds | 2005 (f), 2008 |
| Jonny Harline | 2006 |
| John Beck | 2006 |
| Jake Kuresa | 2006 |
| Jan Jorgensen | 2006 (f) |
| Harvey Unga | 2007 (f), 2008 (so) |
| Dennis Pitta | 2008 (c) |
| Matt Reynolds | 2008 (f) |
| Braden Hansen | 2009 (f) |
| Kyle Van Noy | 2012, 2013 |
| Ezekiel Ansah | 2012 |
| Cody Hoffman | 2012 |
| Riley Stephenson | 2012 |
| Tejan Koroma | 2014 (f), 2017 |
| Thomas Shoaf | 2016 (f) |
| Matt Bushman | 2017 (f) |
| James Empey | 2018 (f) |
| Payton Wilgar | 2019 (f) |
| Brady Christensen | 2020 (c) |
| Jake Oldroyd | 2020 |
| Zach Wilson | 2020 |
| Dax Milne | 2020 |
| Isaac Rex | 2020 (f) |
| Tyler Allgeier | 2021 |
| Clark Barrington | 2021 |
| Campbell Barrington | 2021 (f) |
| Jakob Robinson | 2021 (f) |
| Kingsley Suamataia | 2022 (f) |
| Blake Freeland | 2022 |
| Ryan Rehkow | 2023 |