First Quarter
After a weather delay pushed the start time back 45 minutes, BYU received the opening kickoff, starting at the 35 following a kick out of bounds penalty from Colorado State. Martin got the call first with an inside run, powering his way forward with a nine-yard rush. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick again called a run for Martin on the second play of the game, and Martin moved his way through multiple Ram defenders and then bounced outside. Wide receivers Jojo Phillips and Legend Glasker secured key blocks as Martin worked the sideline and scored a 56-yard touchdown, capping a two-play, 65-yard scoring drive that lasted just 49 seconds. A successful extra point from kicker Matthias Dunn put BYU ahead 7-0 early.
Colorado State responded quickly, with quarterback Hauss Hejny completing passes to RJ Vick and Cedric Ross for 60 yards in just two plays. Penalties from both teams eventually moved the Rams to the BYU 16 for a first-and-goal. Two BYU stops forced a third-and-goal when Hejny found Vick across the middle for a touchdown. Colorado State evened the score 7-7 after a successful PAT with 11:22 left in the first quarter.
Back on offense, BYU began its drive with an 8-yard jet sweep to Glasker. Bachmeier again delivered the ball to Glasker on the next play, a one-handed snag over the corner for 70 yards. From the Rams' 2-yard line, Martin ran up the middle, scoring for the second time after five total plays. Dunn's extra point then put BYU back ahead 14-7 after a three-play, 1:36 drive.
Colorado State shifted to a run-heavy scheme on its next drive. Stops from cornerbacks Therrian Alexander III and Evan Johnson forced a punt, and Bachmeier and the offense took over at the BYU 14. The Cougars worked similarly, running three times and then punting after a three-and-out.
BYU’s defense took the field and forced a quick three-and-out of its own, and the Rams’ punt sailed to Cannon DeVries, whose deep return was negated by a review that put the Cougars at their own 27. On third down, Bachmeier found Glasker with a short crossing route, and the freshman worked his way across the 50 into Rams territory. Bachmeier continued through the air on the next play, passing to tight end Walker Lyons for 26 yards. BYU’s ongoing offensive momentum continued as Martin ran for 10 yards and again for an eight-yard score, marking his third touchdown of the game and 225 total yards of offense for the Cougars in the quarter. Dunn’s successful extra point extended the BYU advantage 21-7.
With Colorado State’s Hejny sidelined, K’saan Farrar took the lead for the Rams on offense, and the quarter came to a close.