Big 12: 2024-
MPSF: 2012-23
| Year | Athlete | Swim/Dive |
| 2024 (15) | Darwin Anderson | Swim |
| Jacob Ballard | Swim | |
| Diego Camacho Salgado | Swim | |
| Cody Dreesen | Dive | |
| Emerson Edwards | Swim | |
| Chase Hindmarsh | Dive | |
| Fletcher Madsen | Swim | |
| Nathan Marshall | Dive | |
| Payton Plumb | Swim | |
| Brad Prolo | Swim | |
| Tony Puertas | Swim | |
| Luigi Riva | Swim | |
| Mickey Strauss | Dive | |
| Jordan Tiffany | Swim | |
| Tama Tuitama | Swim | |
| 2023 (13) | Jacob Ballard | Swim |
| Abraham Barragan | Swim | |
| Diego Camacho Salgado | Swim | |
| Cody Dreesen | Dive | |
| Emerson Edwards | Swim | |
| Brigham Harrison | Swim | |
| Chase Hindmarsh | Dive | |
| Tanner Murphy | Swim | |
| Brad Prolo | Swim | |
| Tony Puertas | Swim | |
| Luigi Riva | Swim | |
| Tama Tuitama | Swim | |
| Evan VanderSluis | Swim | |
| 2022 (10) | Cody Dreesen | Dive |
| Izaak Hajek | Swim | |
| Brigham Harrison | Swim | |
| Eric Muir | Dive | |
| Christopher Pierce | Swim | |
| Brad Prolo | Swim | |
| Tony Puertas | Swim | |
| Connor Stirling | Swim | |
| Mickey Strauss | Dive | |
| Roger Woods | Swim | |
| 2021 (11) | Kimble Mahler | Dive |
| Ryan Sorensen | Swim | |
| Ryan Evans | Dive | |
| Brayden Murphy | Swim | |
| Morgan Cooper | Dive | |
| Ethan Kramer | Swim | |
| Garrett Anderson | Swim | |
| James Sorensen | Swim | |
| Eric Muir | Dive | |
| Roger Woods | Swim | |
| Javier Nicolas Matta | Swim | |
| 2020 (11) | Kimble Mahler | Dive |
| Ryan Sorensen | Swim | |
| Ryan Evans | Dive | |
| Brayden Murphy | Swim | |
| Morgan Cooper | Dive | |
| Ethan Kramer | Swim | |
| Garrett Anderson | Swim | |
| James Sorensen | Swim | |
| Eric Muir | Dive | |
| Roger Woods | Swim | |
| Javier Nicolas Matta | Swim | |
| 2019 (13) | Glenn Abernethy | Swim |
| Evan Berger | Swim | |
| Morgan Cooper | Dive | |
| Bryce Farabee | Dive | |
| Levi Jensen | Swim | |
| Cameron Lindsay | Swim | |
| Kimble Mahler | Dive | |
| John Morris | Swim | |
| Brayden Murphy | Swim | |
| Nathan Rogers | Swim | |
| James Sorensen | Swim | |
| Ryan Sorensen | Swim | |
| Connor Stirling | Swim | |
| 2018 (9) | Evan Berger | Swim |
| Matt Denkers | Dive | |
| David Harlan | Swim | |
| Preston Jenkins | Swim | |
| John Morris | Swim | |
| Levi Jensen | Swim | |
| Nathan Rogers | Swim | |
| James Sorensen | Swim | |
| Luis Ventura | Swim | |
| 2017 (12) | Kent Fellows | Swim |
| Matt Denkers | Dive | |
| Jordan Tuckfield | Dive | |
| Seth Russell | Swim | |
| Rainer Ng | Swim | |
| Nathan Rogers | Swim | |
| Preston Jenkins | Swim | |
| Kevin Dreesen | Dive | |
| David Harlan | Swim | |
| Luis Ventura | Swim | |
| Trayton Speth | Dive | |
| Cameron Lindsay | Swim | |
| 2016 (14) | Matt Denkers | Dive |
| Kevin Dreesen | Dive | |
| Kent Fellows | Swim | |
| David Harlan | Swim | |
| Nathan Henderson | Swim | |
| Preston Jenkins | Swim | |
| Rainer Ng | Swim | |
| Stephen Richards | Swim | |
| Seth Russell | Swim | |
| Chad Sorensen | Swim | |
| Scott Sorensen | Swim | |
| Trayton Speth | Dive | |
| Jordan Tuckfield | Dive | |
| Luis Ventura | Swim | |
| 2015 (11) | Mitchell Allphin | Swim |
| Kevin Dreesen | Dive | |
| Nathan Henderson | Swim | |
| Matt Hopper | Dive | |
| Daniel Kelly | Swim | |
| Rainer Ng | Swim | |
| Hayden Palmer | Swim | |
| Stephen Richards | Swim | |
| Seth Russell | Swim | |
| Chad Sorensen | Swim | |
| Jordan Tuckfield | Dive | |
| 2014 (11) | David Corless | Dive |
| Chad Sorensen | Swim | |
| Andrew Rutherfurd | Swim | |
| Matt Hopper | Dive | |
| Stephen Richards | Swim | |
| Jordan Fletcher | Swim | |
| Edward Young | Dive | |
| Brent Stevenson | Swim | |
| Hayden Palmer | Swim | |
| Dallin Johnson | Swim | |
| Rafael Alfaro | Swim | |
| 2013 (14) | David Corless | Dive |
| Andrew Rutherfurd | Swim | |
| Matt Hopper | Dive | |
| Jordan Fletcher | Swim | |
| Brady Wells | Swim | |
| Daniel Hofstedt | Swim | |
| Joshua Tanner | Swim | |
| Garret Beaman | Swim | |
| Robert Miner | Dive | |
| Hayden Palmer | Swim | |
| David Armstrong | Swim | |
| Christian Hanselman | Swim | |
| Gary Arthur | Swim | |
| Stott Bushnell | Swim | |
| 2012 (11) | Andrew Rutherfurd | Swim |
| Travis Day | Dive | |
| Chad Fong | Swim | |
| Daniel Bates | Swim | |
| Jordan Fletcher | Swim | |
| Garret Beaman | Swim | |
| Brady Wells | Swim | |
| Brandon Watson | Dive | |
| Gary Arthur | Swim | |
| Stott Bushnell | Swim | |
| Robert Miner | Swim |