BYU has had 39 athletes earn 116 All-America citations in its history, including 40 named first-, second-, or third-team AVCA All-America. The 40 All-Americans is good for 10th all-time among Division I programs.
In 2018, six Cougars earned an All-America citation, the most in a single season in program history.
| All-Americans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Year | Player | Outlet | Team |
| 2024 | Claire Little | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| Volleyball Mag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2023 | Whitney Bower | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| Volleyball Mag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| Erin Livingston | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Volleyball Mag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2022 | Heather Gneiting | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| Erin Livingston | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2021 | Kenzie Koerber | AVCA | 3rd |
| VolleyballMag.com | 3rd | ||
| Whitney Bower | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 3rd | ||
| Kennedy Eschenberg | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| Heather Gneiting | VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | |
| 2020-21 | Kennedy Eschenberg | AVCA | 3rd |
| VolleyballMag.com | 4th | ||
| Taylen Ballard-Nixon | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| Whitney Bower | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 3rd | ||
| 2019 | Mary Lake | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| VolleyballMag.com | 3rd | ||
| McKenna Miller | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 3rd | ||
| Whitney Bower | VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | |
| 2018 | Roni Jones-Perry | AVCA | 1st |
| VolleyballMag.com | 1st | ||
| Lyndie Haddock Eppich | AVCA | 1st | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 1st | ||
| Mary Lake | AVCA | 2nd | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 1st | ||
| Heather Gneiting | AVCA | 3rd | |
| VolleyballMag.com | 4th | ||
| Kennedy Eschenberg | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| McKenna Miller | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| VolleyballMag.com | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2017 | Roni Jones-Perry | AVCA | 3rd |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| Cosy Burnett | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Mary Lake | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| McKenna Miller | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2016 | Amy Boswell | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| McKenna Miller | AVCA | 3rd | |
| Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2015 | Alexa Gray | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| Amy Boswell | AVCA | 3rd | |
| 2014 | Jennifer Hamson | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| Alexa Gray | AVCA | 2nd | |
| Amy Boswell | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Whitney Young Howard | Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | |
| 2013 | Alexa Gray | AVCA | 3rd |
| 2012 | Jennifer Hamson | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| Alexa Gray | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Heather Hannemann | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Nicole Warner | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| Volleyball Magazine | 3rd | ||
| 2011 | Jennifer Hamson | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| 2007 | Chelsea Goodman | AVCA | 3rd |
| Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | ||
| Rachel Dyer | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| 2006 | Chelsea Goodman | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2005 | Lindsy Hartsock | AVCA | Honorable Mention |
| Lauren Richards Evans | AVCA | Honorable Mention | |
| 2000 | Nina Puikkonen | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 1st | ||
| 1999 | Nina Puikkonen | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| Anna-Lena Smith | AVCA | 2nd | |
| 1998 | Korie Rogers | AVCA | 2nd |
| Anna-Lena Smith | AVCA | 2nd | |
| 1997 | Amy Steele Gant | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Magazine | 1st | ||
| Korie Rogers | AVCA | 2nd | |
| Volleyball Magazine | 2nd | ||
| 1996 | Gale Johnson | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Magazine | 3rd | ||
| Amy Steele Gant | Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | |
| 1995 | Amy Steele Gant | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Magazine | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1994 | Charlene Johnson | AVCA | 2nd |
| 1993 | Charlene Johnson | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Monthly | 3rd | ||
| Michele Fellows | AVCA | 1st | |
| Volleyball Monthly | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Michele Fellows | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention | ||
| Tea Nieminen | AVCA | 2nd | |
| Volleyball Monthly | 3rd | ||
| 1990 | Tea Nieminen | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1988 | Dylann Duncan Ceriani | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Monthly | 2nd | ||
| 1987 | Mariliisa Salmi | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Monthly | 1st | ||
| Jill Sanders Plumb | AVCA | 1st | |
| Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention | ||
| Dylann Duncan Ceriani | AVCA | 2nd | |
| 1986 | Mariliisa Salmi | AVCA | 1st |
| Volleyball Monthly | 1st | ||
| Sari Virtanen | AVCA | 1st | |
| Volleyball Monthly | 1st | ||
| 1985 | Sari Virtanen | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Monthly | 3rd | ||
| 1984 | Karen Doane | AVCA | 2nd |
| Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1983 | Madge Ferreira | Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention |
| 1981 | Lisa Motes Connolly | AVCA | 1st |
| 1979 | Lisa Motes Connolly | Volleyball Monthly | Honorable Mention |
| 1977 | Annette Cottle | Volleyball Monthly | 2nd |
| Karen Curtis Lamb | Volleyball Monthly | 2nd | |
| All-Freshman Team | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Player | Outlet |
| 2019 | Whitney Bower | VolleyballMag.com (Honorable Mention) |
| 2018 | Heather Gneiting | VolleyballMag.com |
| 1999 | Sunny Tonga Mahe | Volleyball Magazine |
| 1998 | Nina Puikkonen | Volleyball Magazine |
| 1991 | Charlene Johnson | Volleyball Magazine |