All-Americans
| Year | Name | Position | Team | Organization |
|---|
| 2023 | Austin Deming | 3B | 3rd | Collegiate Baseball, NCBWA |
| 2016 | Michael Rucker | RHP | 3rd | Collegiate Baseball, NCBWA |
| 2007 | Jesse Craig | RHP | 3rd | Ping! Baseball |
| 2006 | Ben Saylor | OF | 3rd | ABCA, Collegiate Baseball, NCBWA |
| 2005 | Brandon Taylor | 3B | 3rd | Collegiate Baseball, NCBWA |
| 2002 | Dave Jensen | 1B | 3rd | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2001 | Nate Fernley | RHP | 2nd | Baseball America, Collegiate Baseball |
| 1994 | Ryan Hall | DH | 1st | ABCA, Collegiate Baseball |
| 1993 | Brian Banks | OF | | ABCA, Baseball News |
| 1990 | Gary Daniels | OF | 3rd | ABCA, Baseball America |
| | Randy Wilstead | 1B | | |
| 1989 | John DeSilva | RHP | 2nd | Baseball America |
| | Randy Wilstead | 1B | 2nd | ABCA |
| | Paul Cluff | 2B | | |
| 1988 | Mike Willes | DH | 1st | ABCA |
| | | | 2nd | Baseball America |
| | Paul Cluff | 2B | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1987 | Mike Willes | UTL | 1st | ABCA |
| | Gary Schoonover | SS | 2nd | ABCA |
| 1986 | Gary Cooper | OF | 1st | ABCA |
| 1985 | Gary Cooper | OF | 1st | ABCA |
| 1984 | Cory Snyder | UTL | 1st | ABCA |
| 1983 | Wally Joyner | 1B | 2nd | ABCA |
| | Scott Nielsen | RHP | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1982 | Cory Snyder | | | Baseball News |
| | Scott Nielsen | RHP | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1981 | Peter Kendrick | LHP | 2nd | Baseball News |
| | | | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1979 | Murphy Su'a | 3B | 1st | ABCA |
| | Marc Thomas | OF | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1978 | Cam Killebrew | DH | 2nd | ABCA |
| | Marc Thomas | OF | 2nd | ABCA |
| 1977 | Kim Nelson | 3B | 2nd | ABCA |
| 1976 | Kim Nelson | 3B | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1975 | Mike Moss | C | 3rd | ABCA |
| | Ron Hill | 2B | | |
| 1974 | Lee Iorg | OF | 1st | ABCA |
| 1971 | Dane Iorg | OF | 1st | ABCA |
| 1970 | Doug Howard | 1B | 1st | ABCA |
| 1969 | Doug Howard | 1B | 2nd | ABCA |
| | Richard Zinniger | LHP | 3rd | ABCA |
| 1967 | Dennis Lamb | 3B | 3rd | ABCA |
Freshman All-Americans
| Year | Name | Position | Organization |
|---|
| 2021 | Andrew Pintar | INF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2019 | Reid McLaughlin | RHP | Collegiate Baseball, Perfect Game |
| 2018 | Drew Zimmerman | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2016 | Keaton Kringlen | OF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2015 | Colton Shaver | DH | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2013 | Jacob Hannemann | OF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2012 | Mason Marshall | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2011 | Jaycob Brugman | OF | Collegiate Baseball |
| | Kolton Mahoney | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| | Desmond Poulson | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2009 | Marc Oslund | RHP | Ping!Baseball |
| 2007 | Steve Parker | INF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2006 | Jordan Muir | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2005 | Sean McNaughton | INF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2001 | Justin Su'a | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 2000 | Matt Carson | OF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 1999 | Dave Jensen | INF | Collegiate Baseball |
| 1997 | Spencer Oborn | OF | Baseball America, Collegiate Baseball |
| | Jeff Stone | LHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 1996 | Brett McDermaid | RHP | Collegiate Baseball |
| 1995 | Brad Winget | INF | Baseball America, Collegiate Baseball |
Consensus All-Americans
| Year | Name | Position |
|---|
| 1994 | Ryan Hall | DH |
| 1988 | Mike Willes | DH |
| 1987 | Mike Willes | UTL |
| 1986 | Gary Cooper | OF |
| 1985 | Gary Cooper | OF |
| 1984 | Cory Snyder | UTL |
| 1979 | Murphy Su'a | 3B |
| 1974 | Lee Iorg | OF |
| 1971 | Dane Iorg | OF |
| 1970 | Doug Howard | 1B |
Note: Consensus All-Americans are those players selected highest and most often to All-America teams that are officially recognized by the NCAA for their respective positions
