BYU has had 14 athletes earn 27 All-America citaitons in its history, including nine named first-, second- or third-team National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA) All-America. The Cougars have also had three athletes named Academic All-Americans.
| All-Americans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Position | Year | Recognition |
| Ilove'a Brittingham | C/OF | 2025 | NFCA (3rd), D1 Softball (Freshman), Softball America (Freshman) |
| Libby Sugg | C | 2018 | NFCA (3rd) |
| McKenna Bull | P | 2017 | NFCA (3rd) |
| Gordy Bravo | OF | 2013 | Easton (1st) |
| JC Clayton | SS | 2013 | Easton (2nd) |
| 2012 | Easton (2nd) | ||
| Delaney Willard | OF | 2012 | NFCA (1st), Easton (1st) |
| Paige Affleck | P | 2011 | Easton (2nd) |
| Jessica Purcell Fitu | C | 2011 | Easton (3rd) |
| 2009 | NFCA (3rd), Easton (2nd) | ||
| Jodi Norton | 3B | 2007 | Easton (2nd) |
| Jennifer Whiteley | OF | 2007 | Easton (3rd) |
| Ianeta Le'i | 1B | 2006 | NFCA (2nd), Easton (1st) |
| 2005 | Easton (2nd) | ||
| 2004 | Easton (Honorable Mention) | ||
| Lauren Watson Perry | C | 2005 | Easton (2nd) |
| 2003 | Easton (2nd) | ||
| Paige Paramore | C | 2004 | Easton (2nd) |
| Oli Keohohou | OF | 2003 | NFCA (1st), Easton (1st) |
| 2002 | NFCA (1st) | ||
| 2001 | NFCA (1st) | ||
| Academic All-Americans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Position | Year | Team |
| Lacey Hofstedt | OF | 2015 | Third |
| Stacie Toney | 2B | 2012 | Second |
| Jennifer Whiteley | OF | 2007 | Second |