BYU has had 13 athletes earn 24 All-America citaitons in its history, including eight named first-, second- or third-team National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA) All-America. The Cougars have also had three athletes named Academic All-Americans.

Player Position Year Recognition
Libby Sugg C 2018 NFCA (3rd)
McKenna Bull P 2017 NFCA (3rd)
Gordy Bravo OF 2013 Easton (1st)
JC Clayton SS 2013 Easton (2nd)
    2012 Easton (2nd)
Delaney Willard OF 2012 NFCA (1st), Easton (1st)
Paige Affleck P 2011 Easton (2nd)
Jessica Purcell Fitu C 2011 Easton (3rd)
    2009 NFCA (3rd), Easton (2nd)
Jodi Norton 3B 2007 Easton (2nd)
Jennifer Whiteley OF 2007 Easton (3rd)
Ianeta Le'i 1B 2006 NFCA (2nd), Easton (1st)
    2005 Easton (2nd)
    2004 Easton (Honorable Mention)
Lauren Watson Perry C 2005 Easton (2nd)
    2003 Easton (2nd)
Paige Paramore C 2004 Easton (2nd)
Oli Keohohou OF 2003 NFCA (1st), Easton (1st)
    2002 NFCA (1st)
    2001 NFCA (1st)
Academic All-Americans
Player Position Year Team
Lacey Hofstedt OF 2015 Third
Stacie Toney 2B 2012 Second
Jennifer Whiteley OF 2007 Second