Big 12: 2024-
MPSF: 2012-23
| Year | Athlete | Swim/Dive |
| 2024 (24) | Julia Bartell | Swim |
| Megan Bergstrom | Swim | |
| Kylee Conrad | Swim | |
| Sophia DeBergh | Dive | |
| Elle Decker | Swim | |
| Lily Flint | Swim | |
| Daniela Flores Bautista | Swim | |
| Abi Furqueron | Swim | |
| Regan Geldmacher | Swim | |
| Kate Hansen | Swim | |
| Katya Hulse | Swim | |
| Tahis Ibáñez | Swim | |
| Alexia Jackson Hansen | Dive | |
| Hailey Johnson | Dive | |
| Brooklyn Larson Clouse | Dive | |
| Mackenzie Miller Lung | Swim | |
| Emma Marusakova | Swim | |
| Colette Masino | Swim | |
| Jess Nyborg | Swim | |
| Addison Richards | Swim | |
| Victoria Schreiber | Swim | |
| Liza Slade | Swim | |
| Mia Tandingan | Swim | |
| Halli Williams | Swim | |
| 2023 (15) | Megan Bergstrom | Swim |
| Kylee Conrad | Swim | |
| Charlotte Fie'eiki | Swim | |
| Daniela Flores Bautista | Swim | |
| Abi Furqueron | Swim | |
| Regan Geldmacher | Swim | |
| Katie McBratney | Swim | |
| Kate Hansen | Swim | |
| Hailey Johnson | Dive | |
| Brooklyn Larson | Dive | |
| Jess Nyborg | Swim | |
| Addison Richards | Swim | |
| Liza Slade | Swim | |
| Brynn Sproul | Swim | |
| Halli Williams | Swim | |
| 2022 (10) | Ashley Catchpole | Swim |
| Emma Colvin | Swim | |
| Kennedy Cribbs | Dive | |
| Anna Despain | Swim | |
| Kate Hansen | Swim | |
| Rivers Johnson | Swim | |
| Katie McBratney | Swim | |
| Summer Murphy | Swim | |
| Liza Slade | Swim | |
| Brynn Sproul | Swim | |
| 2021 (10) | Kennedy Cribbs | Dive |
| Anna Despain | Swim | |
| Charlotte Fie'eiki | Swim | |
| Gwen Gustafson | Swim | |
| Kaylie Harmon | Dive | |
| Tahis Ibáñez | Swim | |
| Adia London | Dive | |
| Katie McBratney | Swim | |
| Katia Quezada | Swim | |
| Brynn Sproul | Swim | |
| 2020 (16) | Gwen Gustafson | Swim |
| Katie Smith | Swim | |
| Adia London | Dive | |
| Brynn Sproul | Swim | |
| Kennedy Cribbs | Dive | |
| Morgan Mellow-Dopp | Dive | |
| Kaela Call-Harries | Dive | |
| Ellie Smith | Swim | |
| Kaylie Harmon | Dive | |
| Morgan Paul | Dive | |
| Allison Warnick | Swim | |
| Casey Cunningham | Swim | |
| Tiare Coker | Swim | |
| Kali Brown | Swim | |
| Megan Brimhall | Swim | |
| Anna Despain | Swim | |
| 2019 (13) | Kaela Call-Harries | Dive |
| Casey Cunningham | Swim | |
| Brenna Dickson | Swim | |
| Madelyn Flower | Swim | |
| Kelly Hatanaka | Swim | |
| Kaylie Harmon | Dive | |
| Adia London | Dive | |
| Morgan Mellow-Dopp | Dive | |
| Morgan Paul | Dive | |
| Katy Quezada | Swim | |
| Katie Smith | Swim | |
| Alexa Walters | Swim | |
| Allison Warnick | Swim | |
| 2018 (7) | Natalie Bennion | Swim |
| Haley Bertoldo | Swim | |
| Casey Cunningham | Swim | |
| Morgan Mellow-Dopp | Swim | |
| Kelly Hatanaka | Swim | |
| Emma Richards | Swim | |
| Ellie Thornbrue Brinton | Swim | |
| 2017 (17) | Allison McCormick | Swim |
| Samantha Palmer | Swim | |
| Natalie Bennion | Swim | |
| Lilian Moore | Swim | |
| Ellie Thornbrue Brinton | Swim | |
| Hanna Skaggs | Swim | |
| Anna Dahl | Swim | |
| Ashlee Spindler | Swim | |
| Emma Richards | Swim | |
| Keyka Lienhard | Dive | |
| Kelly Hatanaka | Swim | |
| Shelby Johnson | Dive | |
| Kenzie Heffernan | Swim | |
| Vanessa Moffatt | Swim | |
| Alora Foliaki | Swim | |
| Emily To'o | Swim | |
| Riley Merrill | Swim | |
| 2016 (20) | Natalie Bennion | Swim |
| Riley Merrill | Swim | |
| Sarah Bushnell | Swim | |
| Anna Dahl | Swim | |
| Sydney Dahl | Swim | |
| Brenna Dickson | Swim | |
| Alora Foliaki | Swim | |
| Emily Harris | Swim | |
| Shelby Johnson | Dive | |
| Keyka Lienhard | Dive | |
| Samantha Lingenbrink | Swim | |
| Allison McCormick | Swim | |
| Vanessa Moffatt | Swim | |
| Lilian Moore | Swim | |
| Emma Richards | Swim | |
| Hanna Skaggs | Swim | |
| Alexandria Sorensen | Swim | |
| Ashlee Spindler | Swim | |
| Ali Tippetts-Kottcamp | Dive | |
| Emily To'o | Swim | |
| 2015 (12) | Haley Bertoldo | Swim |
| Riley Buer | Swim | |
| Ciera Marsh Keller | Swim | |
| Allison McCormick | Swim | |
| Cheyenne McLaws | Swim | |
| Haley Francois Quinn | Dive | |
| Mackenzie Rands | Dive | |
| Andrea Grant Richards | Swim | |
| Hanna Skaggs | Swim | |
| Alexandria Sorensen | Swim | |
| Ashlee Spindler | Swim | |
| Ali Tippetts-Kottcamp | Dive | |
| 2014 (12) | Alexandria Sorensen | Swim |
| Angela Bennion | Swim | |
| Jessica Ampuero | Swim | |
| Andrea Grant Richards | Swim | |
| Kimberly Doroghian | Swim | |
| Aubree Allen | Swim | |
| Ciera Marsh Keller | Swim | |
| Camille Okelberry | Swim | |
| Alexandra Dodds | Swim | |
| Daniele Vaughan | Swim | |
| Haley Francois Quinn | Dive | |
| Mackenzie Rands | Dive | |
| 2013 (12) | Angela Bennion | Swim |
| Jessica Ampuero | Swim | |
| Amanda Heninger | Swim | |
| Alia Welsh | Swim | |
| Alina Fong | Swim | |
| Kimberly Doroghian | Swim | |
| Alexandra Dodds | Swim | |
| Dayna Christensen | Dive | |
| Taryn Toolson Lewis | Swim | |
| Daniele Vaughan | Swim | |
| Ciera Marsh Keller | Swim | |
| Mackenzie Rands | Dive | |
| 2012 (15) | Erin Pabst | Swim |
| Angela Bennion | Swim | |
| Kelsey Higginson | Swim | |
| Meagan Stone | Swim | |
| Jessica Ampuero | Swim | |
| Kelsey Dickson | Swim | |
| Alina Fong | Swim | |
| Amy Xu | Swim | |
| Alexandra Dodds | Swim | |
| Dayna Christensen | Dive | |
| Daniele Vaughan | Swim | |
| Melissa Manser | Swim | |
| Karalee Fuller | Swim | |
| Taryn Toolson Lewis | Swim | |
| Jody Ellis | Swim |